A well respected Firearms Trainer and Friend, has recently done a video about AR’s vs Shotgun for Home Defense. Follow that Link, and check it out. And then come back here. I am forced to respectfully disagree.
Rob’s demonstration proves the effectiveness at stopping a threat. A shotgun is a devastating weapon. It’s the most potent stopping tool we have. Rob’s conclusion though was that he prefers the AR-15 rifle (or other Modern Sporting Rifle) due to Capacity and Speed of Reload. Which are good points, but forgets the mission and purpose the weapon is employed for. This is for Home Defense. So unless you live in Helms Deep, the shotgun will be the better option.
Wait… is that really true? Would an AR be the better option at Helms Deep?
We saw the Battle of Helms Deep was pretty much going the way of the Defenders for most of the battle. The Orcish Horde was suffering heavy attrition until one thing happened.
The Breeching Orc took several small caliber hits, but his hostile action was not stopped. This is like what an AR-15 would do. Don’t believe me? Read the book “Blackhawk Down” by Mark Bowden. The one the movie of the same name was based on. Great book, and you should have it in your Library. It describes in detail the lack of stopping power that 5.56mm has.
Some “Gun Guys” get a burr up their asses when someone who knows little about guns, says “Clip” instead of “Magazine”. Some gun guys turn into pedantic asshats about this and regardless of the situation just can’t help but to go into full lecture mode to make sure that they beat the “proper terminology” into their heads. And it wouldn’t be so bad if you just said something like “If it has a spring, it’s a magazine,” and move on… But interjecting your “Knowledge Bomb” with the whole looking down your nose, half sneer, and eye rolls only makes you look like a complete jackwagon.
Instead of rolling easy, you guys have to puff out your chest like a Male Sage Grouse trying to impress a Mate. Then once you’ve beaten your point into the ground like your driving railroad spikes, you then act smug as if you’ve fixed some part of the world that was broken and now can be healed thanks to your blessed wisdom dispensation.
Some times I’ve observed the results of this… and it’s not good. You’ve taken a new and curious shooter that wants to learn… and turned them off completely. I’ve seen this happen at Ranges. I’ve seen this happen at Gun Counters. I’ve seen Customers do this to other Customers… and I’ve even seen Gun Counter Guys do this to someone who was a Customer, but suddenly are no longer one. And then they don’t want to go back. Because people don’t like being talked down to. This does us no good and seriously – Who the hell really cares? This isn’t important.
Clips vs Magazines – It doesn’t matter. Both are devices that hold ammunition… That’s close enough. It’s not “Shoulder Thing that Goes Up” level of ignorance… So let’s let this shit slide and then offer some educational training in a more subtle way, okay?
I was asked what I thought about the Remington R51 Re-Release.
Look… I wanted to like the R51. I really did. I think it looks cool, and I like the idea of an all metal single stacked 9mm, that’s not a 1911, Kahr, or SIG P225… just for the sake of variety. I really wanted to like it. But a couple things gave me pause. One, is the Pederson Hesitation Lock system it uses… which is… just not that good. Then Remington made a very limited invitation only special pre-release introduction for certain Gun Media guys with a history of liking everything that comes their way. Okay, that’s fine… They wanted good impressions to get out there. Sure. Every Gun Company wants that. But the warning lights started flashing when shortly there after at the Media Day at the Range, the day before SHOT SHOW that year – The Remington R51 was suspiciously absent.
Warning Klaxons sounded in my head when at the Remington Booth, Remington Employees were physically blocking people from getting to where the R51 was on display. They stood around the display like defensive Musk Ox surrounding their young.
Remington Reps protecting the R51 at SHOT SHOW.
They wanted Dealers to order them… they just didn’t want anyone to actually touch it. But I did. I went around behind them, went behind a counter, and got in to where it was hanging on the wall, behind the Remington People. I could tell from the expressions on their faces when they saw me – that they were pissed.
When I handled the gun… I liked the size and weight just fine. But the action felt like it was broken inside. That hesitation lock felt like it was going to be a Jam Maker. The Grip Safety was awkward as it pivoted backwards from normal, it had sharp edges of the frame exposed when the safety was depressed.
I warned people to avoid being an early adopter of the R51.
Turns out I was right, and all the pistols I had warned people about – all got recalled. The gun was a bigger pile of crap than I had expected it to be.
Now, fast forward and Big Green is releasing the gun again. All the work to rebuild the gun, all the new engineering and testing… should have been done before it was released to begin with. It should have been tested – thoroughly – before it was released. This was Remington’s fault, resting squarely on the shoulders of Remington. But Remington pointed their fingers at Para USA, in Charlotte, NC…. where the R51 was being produced. This wasn’t a quality control issue… this was a DESIGN ISSUE. And guys at Para were saying “This isn’t right”. Turns out that the guys at Para were right as well. Because to fix the gun, Remington didn’t have to tight QC on the production line… they had to re-engineer the bloody handgun. Proving that it was indeed, a design issue.
Maybe the gun is now “fixed”. But the first people to test it and say it’s fine – are some of the first people that said it was good to go the first time. I have a bit of a problem with that. When asked by a friend what my initial thoughts were about the new again R51… my knee-jerk reaction was “I’d rather have a Bersa.”
So my advice is the same as before. Avoid being an Early Adopter of these R51 2.0’s.
As soon as the Captain was far enough away, Sergeant Weston leaned over to Lt Clayton and said softly, “Why do you act the nutter when the Captain is about?”
Philip Clayton grinned, “He thinks I’m mad, so he doesn’t give me any administrative jobs. And it’s a grand sport! Now hand me my clothes, I am freezing my nipples off.”
Sergeant Weston grabbed the small bundle of pants, shirt, and a jacket, and tossed them to the Lieutenant who started dressing as quickly as he could as he was just starting to shiver. A few minutes later Trucks One and Two fired up their engines. Weston fired up Anvil and Lt Clayton jumped in, pulling a woolen cap down over his ears. Continue reading Kassarine Lost: Part 5→
The movie HEAT is notorious. It had a huge effect across the USA. Because of this movie, cops are now wearing heavier levels of body armor and carry rifles more often than shotguns in many departments around the country. This is because the bad guys saw this movie too… and decided to do it like that did. Especially 2 fellows who held up a Bank Of America in LA. This flick also had an effect on Hollywood. Since then many movie makers have strived for more realistic gun fight scenes. The reason is because HEAT has the best gun battle in it. Ask any group of gun nuts about celluloid fire fights, and HEAT will always come up. Always. Enough has been said about he movie by me and every other critic out there, so I’ll just do what I do and talk about the guns.
The movie RONIN is on of the more interesting action movies out there. The story line is simple and the plot is pretty straight forward, but it is subtle. Action movies traditionally are about as subtle as a brick to the head, so this sets Ronin apart.
I’m not going to lecture about the details and philosophy of the Matrix universe. What I’m going to do instead is an attempt to examine the firearms used in the movies and why the characters would use them. So, let us begin at the beginning.
It came out the Terrorist in the Baton Rouge police ambush used an IWI Tavor rifle. Some words were thrown out by some media sources. “Assault Rifle”, “High Powered”, “Sniper Rifle”.
It’s not an assault rifle. Sure, it’s similar to the weapon used by the Israeli Defense Forces… But it is not a select fire weapon. The TAVOR doesn’t have a Shoulder Thing That Goes Up. It does not have a Bayonet Lug. It doesn’t have a Heat Shield. It doesn’t have an Adjustable Stock. So by all definitions, it’s not an assault rifle.
It’s chambered in 5.56mm – which is .22 Caliber. 5.56mm Nato is based on the .223 Remington cartridge. (Note the first two numbers after the decimal point is “22”) The .223 Remington was designed as a Varmint round. Varmints as being small critters like Rabbits and Squirrels. On many boxes of .223 ammunition, you’ll see images of small rodent type animals. Not Big Game. Not even a small White Tail Deer. So it’s not a “High Powered” rifle. Not even close.
What made the Tavor so deadly was the Man Behind the Trigger. Who was trained in the use of firearms, yes… But the man had EVIL intent. This is the difference between the the Good Guys and the Bad Guys.
What he used as his tool is not important. In France, we saw the tool was a truck. In Boston, we saw the tools were Pressure Cookers. The tool doesn’t matter. It’s how it’s used.
In both cases – Extreme Hate was the catalyst for Evil thoughts to be turned into extreme actions and Evil was carried out. The Tool doesn’t matter, where he got the tool, doesn’t matter. What matters is that it started with Hate.
I get asked this a lot. Do I build my new AR, or do I buy my new AR? That’s a good question. First, let’s talk about the economics of it:
This guy, I don’t know this guy. But he makes a lot of sense. If you are buying a rifle in that 1000 or Less price range.
Or what you do is spend a bit more out of the gate and buy a rifle that is closer to your ideal of the final configuration you want. There’s a lot of rifles out there in the 1500 range that come pretty much done out of the box. Or even less. I’ve seen some very good builds that are complete and good to go for about 1200.
Unless you are wanting a lot of specialized aftermarket stuff with spiky bits or excessive milling for either weight or cosmetic purposes… stuff that isn’t available OEM from anyone… Then building makes sense money wise.
Or you just want a Cheap Out build. And you are going to be shopping for low cost parts. Then in that case, you are going to end up with a Cheap Rifle. I can’t tell you how many times guys have shown me their Cheap Out Build and then they blow sunshine at me that it’s Custom. No, it’s not Custom. It’s a Cheap Out Build you put together on your coffee table. That’s not impressive, so don’t expect me to act impressed. And don’t get mad at me for not being impressed. Anyone can order those same parts from Brownells and Midway USA. A Cheap Out Build though, can get you into an AR for the same or less than most entry level AR’s. I’ve seen some Cheap Out Builds that were about 400 bucks that were actually solid AR’s. So if you do it RIGHT, you can really have something. The problem though is too often, it’s not done right and the result is just another cheap AR.
Another reason to build your AR is that you BUILD your AR. You might need some help or borrow some tools or even buy some tools… But the end result is your own rifle you put together yourself. There’s a lot of satisfaction in that. And if that’s your goal, and you are happy with the rifle – Awesome. That’s all that matters. That’s all that’s important. Because at this point in the AR Market – NO ONE CARES. Do your own thing, be your own man. You only need to impress yourself.
The 3 Things to Splurge on:
1. The Barrel.
2. The Trigger.
3. The Optic.
Spare no expense on these items. Expensive BCG’s are over rated. Expensive fore grips and stocks, are over rated. Back Up Iron Sights, unless you are going to run Iron Sights, are over rated.
In my Church, I’m the Goto Guy for Emergency Preparation. Officially. It’s my job in the church to know and teach this stuff. CNET even reached out to me for information about EP and what they need to keep their Tech going in the case something bad happened… like their power went out. Or they had to go outside.
I wish I had this before CNET talked to me… Because I’d have just said “Get a Sunjack”.
