The Scout Rifle concept isn’t a hard set of Rules that Define a Scout Rifle as a Scout. They are really just guidelines that are flexible to fit within your needs, not someone else’s definition of what your needs are.
I had dinner with Jeff Cooper many moons ago. We talked for a good while about the Scout Rifle as a Concept and about the Steyr Scout specifically. He truly loved the concept… but not so much the Steyr product that bore it’s name at the time. He indicated that it captured the concept for the most part, but was not perfect.
For example… .308. Jeff Cooper himself, who made up the concept only used .308 as an example. He did not say that it HAS to be .308. Evidence to support my assertion, he was also fond of the .376 Steyr cartridge and shot his .376 Scout rifle quite a bit. He also had a .358 Lion Scout concept, which turned into the .376, which he called his Scout Dragoon. All were following the Scout Concept, not a hard set of rules.
The main concept of the caliber for a scout is that it’s a cartridge potent enough for your area of operation, and in a common caliber so ammo availability isn’t an issue. .308 Win is a great option, but not the only option. .30-30, .307 Win, 7.62x39mm… .300 BLK, and yes, even 5.56mm… pretty much any cartridge you can get your hands on that serves for 95% of your likely targets is going to work just fine for YOUR SCOUT.
The Forward Mounted Optic is also not a Requirement, but a configuration that Jeff Cooper found to work well with his Scout Concept. But many Scouts can use a normal configuration of scope, Red Dot, or other Optical Gunsight.
What the Scout boils down to is a light, handy, jack of all trades rifle that can do most of the practical things you might need a rifle for out in the field. A General Purpose Rifle, rather than something specialized. But “General Purpose” sounds Generic and unappealing.
In my opinion, the best Scout rifles I’ve seen are actually .30-30 Lever Actions… what are called “Lever Scouts”. They fit Cooper’s Philosophy of Use just about perfectly. They are light, thin, handy, and potent enough. They have a reasonable capacity, reasonably accurate, and always have and always will embody the Scout concept – arguably more than some Scout rifles which are too bulky and heavy for the intended purpose. In fact… Take any Marlin Lever Action in .30-30 and put a decent Sling on it… and your done. You have your Scout.
Lever Scouts > Bolt Scout.
The cheapest scout would be a Mosin-Nagant M38 with a pistol scope on it …
Mine lives in the trunk, in a sealed plastic bag.
Keep it oily!
The bag is sealed, the rifle oiled, with a desiccant can thrown in.
I am jealous that you were able to speak with the Colonel at length. It must have been eye opening as well as a distinct and memorial pleasure.
Cooper may have been somewhat open to calibers other than .308, but it should be noted that he referred to Steyr’s .223 version as the “Poodle Scout” in his commentaries. It was quite clear that he felt .308 was the proper caliber for a scout, or maybe 7mm-08 for countries that restrict “military” calibers.
In my discussion with him… he mentioned .308 as a wise common option, but not a requirement. “If you had an Enfield in .303, you could make a fine Scout of it.”
Several years ago, I got lucky and won a Gunbroker auction for a .30-06 rifle that someone had built into a Scout Rifle configuration using a M1903 Springfield action – and the builder did a pretty credible job of it, with a custom barrel mount for the Burris IER scope that had an integral front sight post, lightweight Ram-Line synthetic stock, nylon Ching sling, and black Moly-Kote finish.
I call it “Kit Carson, the Army Scout”…
Nice!
Had an M1A Scout once.
Never could get comfortable with the long eye relief scope, so I stuck an Eotech on it. That was a little better, but I finally took the mount off and put a regular heat-shield on it and ran it bush rifle style.
I wish I still had it as it would make a great gun for hunting from a shoothouse.
Could you imagine how quiet a .300 blackout scout would be with a silencer and subsonics? I may have to send an email to Ruger.
That would indeed be nice.