There is much talk on the Internets about choosing your Stance and that you should train that Stance. I think this is wrong. Obviously everyone will have their favorites and will argue them. But I think we need to learn them all.
I find Weaver is good for shorter range work, Iso for intermediate or fast action, and Chapman for longer range work. I don’t think I can use just one for all defensive scenarios. And I think training only one is doing a disservice to yourself or your students if you’re a Trainer.
During the MAG-40 Class last week, Massad Ayoob teaches his students these three basic Stances. I teach them as well. While I’ve never really thought about it much I looked at the people who were shooting best in these stances. For the most part, it was the big burly guys tended to shoot Weaver the best or said they preferred it. Most everyone else liked or shot better with the other classic stances. At the 15 yard line, everyone shoots 6 rounds from Each of the Stances, but gives the Female Shooters the option of not using the Weaver.
If we’re teaching a method that only big strong dudes who can overpower the stance, then it doesn’t work for everyone. I used to shoot Weaver all the time but found that I do better with the others. So why are we even still teaching Weaver? Isn’t this now Archaic to the point we should only think of it in terms of Black and White photos and the FBI Crouch and just shake our heads and comfort ourselves with our opinion that we are so vastly superior now days?
No, not really. Because like much in the Gun Community, everything has it’s place. And Weaver is still a very valid Stance to Learn and strive to Master.
If you are standing near a Stranger, in the Field Interview position, a couple feet away, Gun Side away from the Stranger… You are set up for a Weaver Stance in case you have to go to Guns on the Stranger. There’s one very good reason. And you’ll find that you take this stance quite readily. I’ve never talked to a Cop that I didn’t know that initially addressed me from a position ready to go Iso on me. Because form a Martial Arts standpoint, it would be completely wrong.
Let’s say you are in your car. Your Torso is not a Turret that will allow you to go Iso by traversing at your waste. If you can, I’d like to see that. Take the car out of it. Let’s say you are in a Wheel Chair and something happens to the Left or Right of you. Or just sitting in a Cafe. If you have to go to guns quickly, you may not be able to stand up, spread your feet and stick your arms out to full extension.
These are just a couple cases where you pretty much have no other option than to use the Weaver. Sure, you could then move into your other Stances, but the initial action response is from Weaver. And wouldn’t it be nice to End the hostilities right then and there?
So for you Dedicated Chapmans and Isos… You still need to Train with the Weaver Stances.